1990 INSC 0354
Sushil K. Arora and Another
v.
State of Haryana and Others
(Supreme Court Of India)
HON'BLE JUSTICE KULDIP SINGH HON'BLE JUSTICE M. H. KANIA
Civil Appeal No. 3837 Of 1990 | 07-08-1990

1. On the application of the petitioner, the names of Respondents 12, 13 and 18 are
deleted from the cause title

2. Special leave granted. Counsel heard

3. In our view, a fresh list should be prepared by the Government of Haryana within
three months from today in accordance with the Haryana Service of Engineers, Class
II Public Works Department (Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1970, and in particular Rule 9
thereof. If there are any instructions including those in para 11.4 in the Manual, which
are inconsistent with the Rules, the same will be ignored and the list will be made
strictly in accordance with the Rules, untrammelled by inconsistent observations, if
any, in the judgment of the High Court. It is clarified that if any promotions had been
made earlier in accordance with the Rules, the same shall not be disturbed. The appeal
is disposed of as aforestated. No order as to costs.

1  SpotLaw