1999 INSC 0471
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Secy., Deptt. of Post

Vs.

Chander Pal Singh

                             (S.P.Bharucha, R.C.Lahoti and N.Santosh Hedge JJ.)

06.04.1999

ORDER

The Text below is only a summarized version of the order pronounced

Secy. Deptt. Of post and Ors. V. Chander Pal Singh While hearing the matter concerning the
conflict of opinion with regard to the Rule 9 (3) of the Post and Telegraphs Extra Departmental
Agents (Conduct and Service) Rules, 1964 it was observed that the judgments were not conflicting
as in one case question of constitutionality of Rule 9(3) was not assailed and as in another the said
Rule was struck down as unconstitutional. The appeal was dismissed upholding the validity of the
Rule 9 (3).